by Ezikiel Coy
![10987677_791645794239485_3638159815884491257_n](https://i0.wp.com/outboise.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/10987677_791645794239485_3638159815884491257_n-240x300.jpg)
He sat across from me in the comfort of my home. I had just made coffee and set up a small workstation out of a TV tray, and had my computer playing Pandora quietly to help make my living room more inviting. After exchanging pleasantries and getting us each a cup of coffee, I sat down across from him with my computer off to the side. I reminded him that we wouldn’t be publishing his name, or any information that I felt could compromise his identity. He smiled, and took a sip from his coffee, and said “I’ve always liked the name Mike, you can call me that.” Mike is 37, divorced just last year, and the father of two young women.
For many of us in Idaho, being openly gay is still potentially social or professional suicide. While the numbers of men or women who aren’t openly gay are unknown, it is important for the pioneers of sexual orientation equality to understand the phobias and anxieties that come with hiding who you are. Mike had been in the closet for years, and he has been a friend of mine for only a short period of time. Since his divorce, he hasn’t spent much time with his two daughters because they live with their mother out of state. Coming out of the closet has turned his life upside down for the last two years. He didn’t so much choose to sit his wife down and tell her, it was more of an accident.
Like many closeted men, Mike would find outlets for his sexual identity. Usually, this would be short hook-ups, though he did tell me that for a while he had a boyfriend outside of his marriage but it was too difficult to be a family man, work full time to provide for his family, and run the risk of having a second relationship so he ended it. When asked about his daughters, Mike choked back tears and clutched his coffee cup.
It’s a touchy subject, but especially with the prevalence of bills such as marriage amendments and Add the Words, it’s important for people to know clearly why our community is fighting to get the right to exist as we were born. I have been hearing a lot about Don Dew and his experience with disability and sexual orientation discrimination while applying for a state job. Clearly, there are still many hurdles to overcome as we progress into the 21st century. Mike’s situation is made even worse because he thought that without being “normal,” he would never be able to have the family he always wanted. Now, his entire family is all but lost to him because he was living a life that started out with lies as a foundation.
His father was “a good old boy,” as he puts it. An old school conservative and a devout Christian, he never wanted his father to find out just how different they were. “He would never accept me if I told him. He still doesn’t know.” He sips his coffee.
In Idaho, it is still possible for homosexuals to be discriminated against by their employers. The Add the Words campaign has worked tirelessly to add sexual and gender identity to the Idaho human rights bill, but so far in vain. One aspect of this struggle is deeply influenced by closeted homosexual and transgendered individuals. Without the highest number of people actively supporting social movements such as the Add the Words campaign there is no hope that such legislation will pass. Without the incentive of safety and community to support individuals it is also unlikely that they will come forward with their sexual identity. On the flip side of that as well, legislation shows the public what acceptable behavior is.
It fascinates me to see this dynamic persevere so prevalently in todays culture, when our gay forefathers have suffered and died in order to achieve for us a relegated second class status within this country. Without the state recognizing the humanity and civil rights of the LGBTQ community, what incentive does that general population have to treat us as equals? How are we supposed to be perceived as human beings if we are consistently being denied the same rights as others within our own state? Thus, a vicious cycle begins where pioneers such as the drag queens of Stonewall create a movement for tolerance by fighting back against the oppression they have inherited after so many hundreds of thousands suffered in silence, only for the generations after them to not share their bravery and stand openly as gay individuals.
Perhaps this article is about those suffering with their choice to stay in the closet, but more then that it is a call to all of those whose cries were just whispers in the night to join the growing roar. Together we can enact change, but we can’t make the changes necessary without also exposing ourselves to the ignorance of the world around us.
Like Mike, many of the gentlemen that I spoke with had families before coming out. One was still married to his wife, terrified of the possibility that she might find out. Unlike bisexual men and women, who can feel emotional and physical validation of their sexual identity regardless of the gender of their partner, closeted homosexual men have a much higher rate of failure in this type of relationship dynamic. Gay men are not satisfied emotionally with their “straight” marriage, regardless of how much joy they get from their children.
In fact, of all the men that I spoke with who had at some point engaged in a pseudo-hetero marriage, they indicated that above the shame and fear they felt because of their hidden sexual identity they wanted to stay in the closet in order to keep their children.
The fact that such anxieties exist in 2015 is horrifying. While a valid emotional response to paternity wanting to do anything in order to keep your children safe, the fact that these men felt that they had to choose between their children and their own pursuit of happiness is sickening. That’s not including the fact that these men lived daily with the fear and stress of looking over their shoulder, making sure that their lies were being believed. Like being on stage 24/7, these men only found reprieve in the quiet moments when no one else was around.
I spoke with several men who engaged in extra-marital affairs on the “down low” in order to maintain their hetero-normative relationship. While they are not proud of these behaviors, it is nearly paralyzing for them to think of an alternative. In their mind, the blowback and destruction of the lives they care about is a worst case scenario–being openly gay would ruin them professionally or personally- they risk decimating their ability to live happy and productive lives. Being openly gay would be the worst choice they could make because everything they have built in their lives so far requires that they be normal straight men. Being gay would be the worst thing they could do in order to pursue social acceptance and validation.
I guess it’s time for that rant, because this thought pattern is so devastating and so rampant. It ties-in to so many thoughts that I find abhorrent: hetero-normative (Monogamous, male/female) relationships are the only ones that can cause satisfaction, gay life is lesser than straight life, self-respect is less important than the approval of others. The thought that “if I am straight I can have kids, I can be happy, I can’t do that if I’m gay.” While none of these thoughts are accurate, they are socially programmed into people from a young age through subtle and subversive ways. Then, when the child grows into a self-aware adult, these lingering constructs create the anxiety and fear that keeps them hiding their sexuality, what they perceive as a disease or a corruption.
Maybe that is what I took a little too personally. Regardless, I am a much more sympathetic these days, having experienced years of abuse, more than one assault, constant ignorant bullying, and a whole host of other things that this beautiful and accepting state has to offer. I don’t blame them for the fear and anxiety that controls their life. It shames me that in a society as vocal and connected as ours still requires people to hide in the shadows disguising their true selves. Sacrificing their potential for a fulfilling happiness in order to fit within the parameters of social programming can be traumatizing.
Of course, whether or not to come out is a deeply personal choice. Being gay is physio-psychologically not a choice, but making yourself known as part of our family certainly is. I cannot advocate a choice that would put any one person on a path of violence, oppression or misunderstanding. It is a deeply personal choice to stay in/come out of the closet, and not every one has the desire for their life to become a role model to so many others. It is not just a matter of being a pedestal within a community, it is a matter of being true to yourself so that it is possible to achieve all that you deserve in life with the person you love (regardless of their gender or sexual identity) standing by your side.
We do not come out in order to become the pariah, we come out so that we can walk the road with our community as a whole. With every one man that is out and openly gay, there are probably two or three that are being silent. For me, this seems unacceptable when so many more of our youth, who have the courage to come forward about their sexual identity, are being exposed to a world that their elders don’t feel safe enough to embrace as who they are. Here, we aren’t just discussing the fear and anxieties that are preexisting in the closeted population. We’re also discussing the droves of youth that are feeling the isolation and anxiety that has spurred a whole wave of teen suicides.
Mike spoke of the isolation that he felt while he was in the closet. The only thing getting him through the divorce and the pain of not seeing his children for months at a time was the community around him that felt and shared his pain. We are always stronger as a community. Supporting those who are not banner waving activists is just as important as fighting for our rights through legislation and social outreach. Without the openly gay aspect of the community, the riot of Stonewall would be in vain; however, without every closeted person at least speaking up we will never know the true extent of our community. We have a unique obligation to speak openly about who we are as people in all of our different permutations so that those who come after us can share our strength. If your coming out of the closet could save one more gay/transgendered teen from bullying, harassment, assault, or suicide, how could you justify staying in the closet?